I Call Bullshit on the Way Society Treats Mental Illness

by Carlo Alcos on November 5, 2012

in Featured, Mental Health

Post image for I Call Bullshit on the Way Society Treats Mental Illness
Take 32 seconds to watch the below video, then sign the declaration at CallBS.ca if you want to help end the stigma of mental illness in our society, and open the way for meaningful discussion.

It can be hard to understand or empathize with people who suffer from mental illness. If you’ve never experienced it yourself or don’t know anyone who suffers from it, you may not even really believe it exists. (Note: chances are you do know someone suffering from mental illness — they just aren’t open about it because they feel shame.)

For much of my life I questioned it. Even though I’d had bouts of extreme sadness I was always able to get out of it quickly and move on with life. It was hard to imagine that others couldn’t just do the same. I had pretty staunch beliefs about medication to treat mental illness, thinking that it was never truly needed, that it was all just about industry and profit for the pharmaceutical companies. (Not that I don’t believe this is partially — maybe mostly — true. Meds are prescribed way too fast and too often when they should be a last resort option.)

I quickly changed my perception about mental illness after becoming close with someone who suffers from it. I saw first-hand how she entered into depressions that were beyond reason, that she couldn’t just turn it around, even though on the outside, to everyone else, she appeared to have it all together and in fact was great at spreading happiness. She has coping tools: meditation, yoga, techniques learned through counseling. She has a deep spiritual practice and is a lover of nature and all beings. Despite all of this though, when she spirals into a depression she becomes hopeless and would rather just disappear off the face of the earth. I’ve seen her eyes, which are normally filled with energy and love, become lifeless. There is no mistaking the eyes.

Despite more than 1 in 5 youth needing mental health services, less than 25% actually receive them. Instead, many suffer in silence due to the shame, stigma and lack of care that exists.

What’s more, suicide is the second leading cause of death for young Canadians, and most who die have a mental illness, like depression. ~ from CallBS.ca

I helped her admit herself into a psych ward, because she needed to be in a safe environment and around others who could understand her. I visited her everyday and saw the other patients who also suffered some very real illnesses, who functioned at a much lower level then she did. I saw the nursing staff, the counselor, the doctor, all who were overworked — each dealing with far more patients than they should have been — because of a medical system that continually strips away mental health funding, presumably because the government feels it’s not important enough.

Our society has something against the mind. It refuses to acknowledge that the mind can, just like any physical part of our body, be “injured.” If you break your leg there’s no questioning it. You have a broken leg. An employer wouldn’t hesitate in hiring you because of it. No one would tell you to just ignore it and walk around like normal. You’d get sympathy from your friends and strangers opening doors for you. Mental illness is real too. It’s harder to see, but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist.

Continuing to act as if it doesn’t exist — keeping it as a dirty little secret — will keep people who suffer from it hidden away, out on the fringes. They will suffer in silence, riddled with shame.

Help call bullshit on this society that perpetuates the stigma of mental illness. Help open the doors for more conversation. Encourage each other to talk openly about it. Stop making people feel bad for feeling bad.

About the author

Carlo is a Managing Editor at Matador Network and co-founder of Confronting Love. He is not a trained therapist, but he's been divorced and has thought about and discussed love and relationships extensively. He is human and alive, qualifying him to continue the conversation. He currently calls Nelson, BC his home. Like him on Facebook and follow him on Twitter.

  • Anne_Merritt

    I’m glad to see a campaign like this, and articles like this, Carlo. I hope your friend is doing well.

    • http://matadornetwork.com/ Carlo Alcos

      Thanks Anne.

  • http://www.facebook.com/halamen80 Hal Amen

    powerful post

  • http://www.candicedoestheworld.com/ Candice Walsh

    Grew up around this sort of stuff my whole life, and you’re right, the lack of support is appalling. This was a great read. We all need to be more honest!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=711400331 Aspen Switzer

    Yup!  I used to have the same thoughts about antidepressant meds as you do Carlo… not anymore.  I am grateful and proud to say I am on them now and have been for over a year.  They have probably saved my life and they have definitely given me a shot at living functionally which is no small thing!  I actually think that depression is under diagnosed and therefore probably under medicated (god the activist in me is cringing!) but the human being in me is celebrating!  Depression is very common and is nothing to be ashamed of!  My generation is three times as likely to suffer from depression than my grandparent’s generation (my psych text book)… that’s kinda a big deal and it is certainly not something to take personally.  

    Like your friend I have practices coming out of the wazoo that help support my well being but when you can’t even go grocery shopping or pick up the phone to call a friend without feeling severe shame who cares about yoga!  When I started taking meds I literally watched myself become functional in ways that I had been battling with for 10 years.  Life still has it’s challenges, it’s ups and downs but now I am available to deal with them.  it is my goal to be off of antidepressants some day and I do a lot of research about diet, exercise, therapy, vitamins and other natural ways to effect brain chemistry and I am excited to get to a point where I won’t need the antidepressants.  However should I need them for the rest of my life I will use them with gratitude!  I am grateful that I live in a time and place where they are available to me (although they are damn expensive) and in a family and community of friends who support whatever choices I make for my mental health.  Depression is not simply being sad.  Needing antidepressants has nothing to do with not being able to handle emotion.  Most people who have been through depression are as tough as nails as it takes a lot to just get through the day with the weight of clinical depression.  

    I am willing to shout from the roof tops that I have depression if it would help take some weight of shame and stigma off of those suffering in silence.  There is help and it is worth reaching for it!  The world needs each of us so lets not lose anyone to this form of mental illness!  Reach out to those around you who seem isolated, it’s almost impossible to reach out when depression has hit hard and most of us are EXTREMELY good at covering it up.  Sometimes it is hard to even recognize ones own depression.  All of a sudden relationships go bad, life feels unmanageable “but who cares, maybe I am crazy or weak”… can be the sentiment.  All humans need to feel human care and connection so if you’re able to express that to those you love do!

    With love and thanks

    • http://matadornetwork.com/ Carlo Alcos

      Love Aspen! Thank you for sharing. I loved this: “Most people who have been through depression are as tough as nails as it takes a lot to just get through the day with the weight of clinical depression.” And that’s a good point you make about it being underdiagnosed…there’s probably a balance there…many people on medication who shouldn’t be (ie it’s just the quick/easy way out for doctors/parents) and others who need it but aren’t. 

      You know, if you want to share more and feel like writing (or have any writing/poetry already) you have a place to publish it here :) Am glad to hear how we’ll you’re doing!

      • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=711400331 Aspen Switzer

        Lovely!  Thank you.  I just might take you up on that.  Great to be in touch xo

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=550120876 Will Klatte

    This is a poem I shared at the poetry slam, about one of my experiences with mental health.

     
    Worst Laid Plans

    I was sitting on a sidewalk patio drinking
    with the man who was the lover of the mother of my son,
    and this guy comes up to bum a smoke.
    Foot dragging and tie-dyed
    he holds a sign,
    cut from a box that holds nothing now.
    “Spare some change for overdose suiside”
    suicide spelled with two S’s and no C,
    and I envied him.
    My suicide notes have been drafted and crafted
    until I realized I didn’t know why I wanted to die sometimes, just that I did.
    And he has his down to six letters.
    He had a plan.

    The nurse that checked me in to the emergency room
    asked me if I had a plan.
    I said “no, I haven’t decided.”
    And when I finally talked to a doctor he asked me “why?”
    “I’m like a stack of sand,” I replied,
    “trying to stand, but the higher I get
    the more unstable I become, and I ‘m tired of collapsing
    into some relapsing heap that is more of a depression.”

    His next question was “do you have a plan?”
    “I don’t understand what you mean.”
    “Do you know how you’ll do it?”
    “No, but if you mean have I identified what I’d do if I did it here,
    like use the cable to the monitor on that table to suspend myself by the neck
    from that light on the ceiling that looks like it could handle my weight,
    or would I take a bottle of whatever those are, then yes, I guess I’ve made a few,
    but I don’t know what I’ll do.”

    The good doctor offered me a bottle of anti-depressants and one of sleeping pills,
    and I have always wondered if they would have been enough to kill myself with.
    I didn’t take any, bullshitted the director of community mental health,
    and left.
    I’m still here, even after later tracing my radial arteries
    with a J.A. Henkles meant for vegetables,
    and thinking better of it.

    Will Klatte

    • http://matadornetwork.com/ Carlo Alcos

      Wow Will. Potent stuff. Thank you for sharing it here.

    • Christine Garvin

      Amazing. Thanks so much for sharing.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=566170446 Carrie Clark

    Many couples misunderstand each other at the best of times.  You understand me even at my worst.  You listen, you hold me, you are silent when necessary, you encourage when the time is right, you never ever make me feel like a failure.  You understand that if I could change I would.  You understand that it is temporary and you celebrate with me when the  lightness returns.  You help to show me I’m worthy of life even when I’m barely hanging on.  You remind me of life when I’m healthy.  You bring joy and comfort.  And when I am well, man, life is good!  I love being with you and I am utterly grateful for you.  Thank you for being such a support, advocate, and sweet sweet man.

  • Cacye

    Dude, you are just an example of lack of imagination.  If you have one, you can well see that a lot of people are not sane, even though they are out walking around.  Just talk to people on the bus, for Christ’s sake.  Talk to homeless people just once.  No one can help it if you are so stuck in your shit you don’t take time to notice anything.

Previous post:

Next post: